Evaluation Of Protective Role Of Thiola Against Carbon Tetrachloride-Induced Histochemical Changes In The Rat Liver

 

SABER A. SAKR1, ESAM I. AGAMY1, MARSEL N. BOULOS2 AND ENAYAT A. OMARA2

 

1-     Department of Zoology, College of Science,

 Menoufia University, Egypt

2-     Department of Pathology, National Research Center,

Cairo, Egypt   

 

تأثير الثيولا على التغيرات الهستوكيميائية المستحثة بواسطة رابع كلوريد الكربون في كبد الفئران

تضمنت هذه الدراسة تأثير مركب الثيولا وهو أحد مركبات السلفهيدريل على التغيرات الهستوكيميائية التي يحدثها رابع كلوريد الكربون في كبد الفئران. أظهرت النتائج أن معاملة الحيوانات برابع كلوريد الكربون لمدة 50 ، 90 ، 130 يوما أدت إلى انخفاض كميات الجليكوجين، المواد البروتينية انخفاضا ملحوظاً في الخلايا الكبدية، بينما زادت كمية الدهون ونشط أنزيم الفوسفاتيز القاعدي. أدى حقن الفئران بمركب الثيولا بعد المعاملة برابع كلوريد الكربون إلى تحسن ملحوظ في المحتوى الهستوكيميائي للكبد فقد ظهر الجليكوجين والبروتينات الكلية بصورة شبه طبيعية بعد إنتهاء الحقن بالثيولا، ونقصت كمية الدهون وأنخفض نشاط أنزيم الفوسفاتيز القاعدي. وقد أستدل من هذه الدراسة أن للثيولا تأثيرا واقيا ضد التغيرات المرضية التي يحدثها رابع كلوريد الكربون.

 

The effect of the sulfhydryl compound (thiola) on the histochemical changes induced by carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) in the liver of rat was investigated after different periods of treatment. A marked decrease of glycogen and total proteins was noticed in the hepatic cells of CCl4 treated rats after 90 and 130 days of treatment. On the other hand, fatty infiltration was markedly observed in the treated liver and increased by increasing the duration of treatment. A marked increase in the activity of alkaline phosphatase appeared in the liver of treated animals, especially in the degenerated areas. Animals treated with CCl4 followed by injection of thiola for 50, 90 and 130 days showed a significant improvement in the liver histochemical parameters. The degree of improvement depended on the period of thiola treatment.

 

Keywords: Liver, carbon tetrachloride, thiola, histochemistry.

 

 


INTRODUCTION

 

Hepatic injury induced by chemicals has been recognized as one of the most toxicological problems. Carbon tetrachloride (CCl4) is one of the hydrocarbons that has a wide spread use in various industries as solvent (El-Dossouky et al. 1978). It is also used in medicine as vermifuge in the treatment of hookworm disease. On the other hand, exposure to CCl4 by inhalation, ingestion or absorption through the skin resulted in many cases of poisoning (Boger et al. 1987).  CCl4 is a potent hepatotoxin in a variety of experimental animals and man. It induced necrosis and cirrhosis (Ishil et al. 1984). Prolonged administration of CCl4 leads to fibrosis, cirrhosis and hepatic carcinoma (Zimmerman & Ishak, 1978).

           Many sulfhydryl compounds have been used extensively for protection against injurious effect of many toxic substances as well as ionizing radiations. Among these compounds found in the living body are cysteine, glutathione and ergothionine.   Thiola (2-mercaptoproionylglycine) is one of the sulfhydryl compounds that contains a weakly-bonded sulfhydryl radical, SH. It has been used for protection against ionizing radiation without any serious toxicity (Sughora et al. 1970). Thiola has been also proven to be effective in management of various forms of liver dysfunction (Tsuji & Nagashima 1981; Ichida et al. 1982; Sakr 1993). It was effective in modulating hepatic alterations following repeated administration of fibrotic agent as CCl4 and ethanol (Torriell et al. 1981). In continuation to our previous study on the effect of thiola on histological changes induced in the rat liver by CCl4 (Sakr et al. 1994), the present work was planned to evaluate the possible preventive role of thiola on histochemical alterations produced by CCl4 in the liver of male albino rats.

 

MATERIALS AND METHODS

           

Adult male albino rats (Rattus norvigus) weighing 70-80 gms were used in the present study. They were fed a standard rodent chow (pellets, Egyptian Ministry of Agriculture) and water was given ad libitum. Animals (110 rats) were divided into four groups.

 

Group I        Animals of this group (25 rats) served as control.

Group II       Animals of this group (30 rats) were injected subcutaneously with 0.1ml CCl4
(32 gm/L) twice weekly for 130 days.

Group III     Animals of this group (30 rats) received the same dose level of CCl4 of those in-group II followed by daily intraperitoneal injection of thiola (1 mg/100gm body weight) for 130 days. Thiola was dissolved in saline and neutralized with NaHCO3 before use.

Group IV     Animals of this group (25 rats) were injected with thiola only.

 

        Eight animals were selected randomly from each group after 50, 90 and 130 days of treatment, sacrificed and prepared for histochemical examination. Small pieces of the liver were quickly removed and fixed in Carnoy’s fluid. Fixed materials were embedded in paraffin wax and sections of 5 microns were cut. Polysaccharide materials were demonstrated using periodic acid - Shiff’s technique PAS (Hockiss 1948). Total proteins were demonstrated by mercury bromophenol blue method (Mazia et al. 1953). Frozen sections stained by oil blue N method were used for demonstration of lipids (McManus & Mowry, 1960). Gomori’s method was used for demonstration of alkaline phosphatase (Moussa et al. 1984).

 

RESULTS

 

GLYCOGEN

 

        In control rats the total carbohydrates exist in the form of deeply stained reddish granules in the cytoplasm of the hepatic cells, as shown by PAS method. All these positively stained materials have been proved to be glycogen as verified by Best’s carmine staining with and without previous treatment with diastase. The nuclei gave a negative reaction (Fig. 1).

        Liver of animals treated with CCl4 for 50 days showed noticeable decrease in glycogen in the cytoplasm of most hepatocytes and the hepatic lobules lost their normal configuration (Fig. 2). Such reduction of glycogen markedly appeared in the liver of animals treated for 90 and 130 days (Fig. 3). Rats treated with CCl4 followed by injection of thiola revealed marked degree of improvement in glycogen contents of the hepatocytes and the liver tissue restored most of its normal structure. Such restoration was seen after 130 days of treatment  (Fig. 4).

 

LIPIDS

        Using oil blue method, lipid materials were stained blue. In the control rat, the liver showed very little lipid inclusions in the form of few blue droplets as well as very fine granules scattered randomly in the cytoplasm (Fig. 5).

            Animals treated with CCl4 showed an increase in lipid droplets. After 50 days of treatment fat droplets were markedly increased in the cytoplasm of the affected hepatocytes. The distribution of fat droplets in some rats was in the mid peripheral zone of liver lobules and in others the droplets were distributed randomly in all the lobules   (Fig. 6).

 

Fig. 1. Section in liver of a control rat showing PAS - positive inclusions (glycogen) in the hepatocytes. x 300. Fig. 2. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 50 days showing a decrease of glycogen. x 300. Fig. 3. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 90 days showing noticeable decrease of glycogen. x 300. Fig. 4. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 followed by thiola for 130 days showing restoration of glycogen contents in most cells. x 300.

In the hepatocytes of animals treated with CCl4 for 90 and 130 days, the extent of visible fat accumulation varied from minute droplets scattered in the cytoplasm of few cells to distention of the entire cytoplasm of the most cells by coalesced droplets (Fig. 7). Animals treated with CCl4 followed by thiola showed gradual decrease in lipid inclusion in the hepatocytes. After 130 days of injection with thiola, these inclusions were markedly decreased as compared with those treated with CCl4 alone (Fig. 8).

 

TOTAL PROTEINS

 

        The proteinic materials in the liver cells were demonstrated by bromophenol blue method. In the control rats, they appeared in the form of small bluish irregular particles which were sometimes closely packed together making blue irregular dense bodies against a weakly to moderately stained ground cytoplasm (Fig. 9).

        Examination of rat liver after treatment with CCl4 for 50 days showed moderate decrease in its proteinic contents (Fig. 10). After administration of CCl4 for 90 and 130 days, the hepatocytes designated a high decrease in their protein materials (Fig. 11). A slight decrease in protein content was observed in the majority of hepatic cells of animals treated with CCl4 followed by thiola
(Fig. 12).

 

ALKALINE PHOSPHATASE

 

        Gomori’s method was used to demonstrate alkaline phosphatase histochemically in tissue fixed in cold acetone. In the liver of control rats, the nuclei of the peripheral cells of the lobule showed a weak alkaline phosphatase activity while the central part showed negligible response. The enzymatic activity in the wall of blood vessels and sinusoids was mild (Fig. 13).

        After administration of CCl4 for 50 days the hepatic cells showed an increase of alkaline phosphatase compared with the controls (Fig. 14). A marked increase in the activity of alkaline phosphatase was observed in the liver of rats treated for 90 and 130 days. Marked reaction was seen in the degenerated areas (Fig. 15). An improvement in the concentration and quantity of alkaline phosphatase content was observed in the liver of animals treated with CCl4 and thiola, and such partial improvement was apparent after 90 days (Fig. 16).

 

Fig. 5. Section in liver of a control rat stained by oil blue N stain showing distribution of lipid granules . x 300. Fig. 6. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 50 days showing lipid droplets distributed in most of the hepatocytes. x 300. Fig. 7. Section in liver of an animal treated with CCl4 for 130 days showing heavy fat accumulation . x 300. Fig. 8. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 and thiola for 130 days showing remarkable depletion in lipid droplets. x 300.

Fig. 9. Section in liver of a control rat stained by bromophenol blue showing strong proteinic materials in the cytoplasm and nucleolus. x 300. Fig. 10. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 50 days showing moderate decrease in proteinic materials in most cells. x 300. Fig. 11. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 130 days showing a marked decrease of proteinic materials. x 300. Fig. 12. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 and thiola for 130 days showing improvement in the amount and distribution of protein as compared with that treated with CCl4 alone. x 300.

 

Fig. 13. Section in liver of a control rat stained by Gomeri’s stain showing alkaline phosphatase activity. x 300. Fig. 14. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 50 days showing increase in alkaline phosphatase activity. x 300. Fig. 15. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 for 90 days showing a high increase in alkaline phosphatase activity in the nucleus of the hepatocytes. x 300. Fig. 16. Section in liver of a rat treated with CCl4 and thiola for 90 days showing moderate alkaline phosphatase activity. x 165.

 

DISCUSSION

 

        Results obtained in the present work indicated that CCl4  treatment induced some histochemical changes in the liver of rats. These results had proceeded in an almost parallel manner to the corresponding histopathological ones reported by Sakr et al. (1994). Treating rats with CCl4 caused marked changes in the glycogen of hepatic cells. However, there was a general tendency toward a decrease in the amount of glycogen, which was marked in the later stages of treatment, especially in the cirrhotic liver.

        The effect of CCl4 on glycogen amount of liver cells was demonstrated by many investigations. Lockard et al. (1983) reported that rats treated with CCl4 showed a temporary decrease in the percentage of hepatocytes with glycogen. CCl4 was found to reduce the quantity of liver glycogen (Trinus et al. 1986; Bernacchi et al. 1988; Kwon et al. 1989) and the quantity of blood glucose (Dubal & Bais 1982). Rastogi & Rama (1990) showed that CCl4 brings about a rise in cytosolic free calcium. It also depletes glycogen and glucose-6-phosphatase level in the liver. Hickenbottom & Hornbrook (1971) reported that depletion of hepatic glycogen, in response to CCl4 treatment, has been linked to changes in activities of glycogen transferase and glycogen phosphorylase.

        Treating rats with CCl4 induced fatty infiltration in the liver starting at 50 days after treatment. This result agree with Itoh (1988) who reported that fatty liver was produced within 3 to 4 weeks after treatment with CCl4. Lockard et al. (1983) found that in addition to morphological changes produced in the liver of rats by CCl4 treatment there was an increase in the number of hepatocytes with fatty infiltration. Kim & Labella (1987) reported that CCl4 caused significant increase in hepatic lipid peroxidation. Levels of total lipid and cholesterol of liver were also increased (Dwived et al. 1990).  It was reported that fatty changes is a common lesion in CCl4 treated liver and this term is used when there is morphological evidence of excess intracytoplasmic fat (Kanase et al. 1986). The mechanism of this change is complex and may be produced by many factors, e.g. organelle injury at different subcellular loci, metabolic disorders, deficiency of essential lipotropic factors, excessive mobilization of fat from extrahepatic sources or varying combinations of any of these factors (Poli et al. 1979).

        Among the findings in the present work is the noticeable decrease of protein content in hepatic cells of CCl4 treated rats. This observation correlates with the results of Lamb et al. (1984) who reported that CCl4 reduced the liver protein content, and found significant decrease of 18% in total hepatic protein and 37% in RNA content in rats given CCl4. Impairment of protein synthesis in CCl4 hepatotoxictiy was reported by several investigators. Treatment with CCl4 caused membrane lipid peroxidation, altered lipid metabolism and decreased protein synthesis in the injured hepatocytes (Pappas et al. 1984; Boger et al. 1987; Hanma 1990).

        Another histochemical change prevailing in the present investigation is the increase in alkaline phosphatase activity in liver of the treated animals. This result agrees with  Sherlock & Walshe (1947) who described an increase of alkaline phosphatase activity in the degenerating and necrotic liver cells. Stowell et al. (1950) found that in cirrhotic liver induced by CCl4 in mice, alkaline phosphatase reaction was increased in the nuclei and nucleoli of the hepatocytes, but the cytoplasm showed no activity. Edress et al. (1980) reported that alkaline phosphatase activity was increased in the liver of human with obstructive biliary cirrhosis, alcoholic cirrhosis and bilharzial cirrhosis.

        The results observed in this work showed that treatment with thiola induced marked improvement in the glycogen, total proteins and lipids of the liver of rats treated with CCl4. However, a partial improvement was recorded in the alkaline phosphatase activity. Similarly, Sakr et al. (1993) found that thiola supplements to methotrexate-treated rats produced marked improvement of the glycogen, total proteins and nucleic acids contents of the liver. The efficiency of thiola and WR 2721 as chemical radioprotectors against gamma radiation was investigated in the skin of mice by El-Bialy et al. (1992). They found that polysaccharides decreased in the skin of irradiated animals. A significant increase in polysaccharides was recorded in skin of animals post-treatment with thiola or WR 2721. El-Aaser et al. (1985) reported that thiola and WR 2721 were found to have a protective effect on protein synthesis in the kidney, liver and intestine of albino rats. The levels of liver triglyceride and serum lipid peroxide increased in rats treated with alcohol, these increases were markedly suppressed in rats treated with alcohol followed by thiola or glutathione (Harata et al. 1982). Torrielli et al. (1981) mentioned that liver fatty infiltration was significantly depressed in animals given glutathione, cysteine or thiola. Mathur et al. (1986) reported that the activity of alkaline phosphatase was increased post-irradiation and after treatment with thiola it showed lesser values.

        Results of the present work provide additional evidence for the protective action of thiola. Thiola is capable of liberating SH group, which has an important physiological function in the human body as an antitoxic agent, and in enzymatic activity (Kumar  1985) However, the multiple effects of sulfhydryl compounds make it difficult to ascertain their exact detoxifying mechanism(s). It is speculated that the protective effect of thiola, out of many alternative mechanisms, most likely is due to its capacity as SH donor. This SH group may act directly through a conjugative reaction with CCl4 or its metabolites (Sakr et al. 1994) leading to inhibition of its hepatotoxic action.

 

REFERENCES

 

Bernacchi, A. S., Fermandez, G., Vilarrenal, M. C. & Castro, J. A. 1988. Further studies on late preventive effects of the anticalmodulin trifloroperazine on carbon tetrachloide-induced liver necrosis. Experimental and Molecular Pathology 48: 286-300.

 

Boger, M., Applemen, L. M., Feron, V. J., Beens, R. B. & Notten, W. R. 1987. Effect of the exposure profile on the inhalation toxicity of carbon tetrachoide in male rats. Journal of Applied Toxicology 7: 185-192.

 

Dubale, M. S. & Bais, R. 1982. Effect of carbon tetrachloide on quantity of blood sugar and liver glycogen in Rattus rattus. Journal of Animal Morphology and Physiology  28: 216-220.

 

Dwived, Y., Rastogi, R., Chander, R. & Dhawan, I. V. 1990. Hepatoprotective activity of picroliv against carbon tetrachloride-induced liver damage in rats. Indian Journal of Medical Research  92: 195-200.

 

Edrees, A. Z., El-Naby, M.T., Kamel, M. Z. & Fahmy, N. A. 1980. Histological and histochemical studies on normal and diseased biliary passages. Egyptian Journal of Histology 3: 91-96.

 

El-Aaser, A. A., Roushdy, H. M., Gerges, R. B. & Osman, S. A. 1985. Control of irradiation induced disorders in protein metabolism of irradiated mice. Second National  Congress of Biochemistry, Cairo, Egypt.

 

El-Bialy, M. G., El-Aaser, A. A., Shawky, A. R., Mokhtar, N. M. & Hafez, M. N. 1992. Evaluation of protective role of thiola and W.R. 2721 against biolgical effect of radiation exposure. Journal of Egyptian German Society of Zoology  7: 25-40.

 

El-Dossouky, E. A., MiKhal, T. H., Awadallah, R. & Kotlo, N. A. 1978. Effect of phenobarbitone and propionyl promazine on serum enzyme in carbon tetrachloride hepatotoxicity, Zeitschrift fur Ermahrungswissenschaft  17: 159-168.

 

Hanma, T. 1990. Effect of trichloroethylene, 1, 1, 1-trichlor anthrene and carbon tetrachloide on plasma lipoproteins of rats. Indian Journal of Health 28: 159-174.

 

Harata, J. Nagata, M. O., Ohta, T. & Yamazaki, M. 1982. Effect of 2-mercaptopropionyl glycine and glutathione on the concentration of alcohol in the blood after peroral administration of alcohol and alcohol dehydrogenase in the liver of rabbit. Japanese Journal of Alcohol Studies and Drug Dependent  17: 341-352.

 

Hickenbottom, R. S. & Hornbrook, K. R. 1971. Effect of carbon tetrachloride on mechanism of liver glycogen in the rat. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapy  178: 383-394.

 

Hockiss, R. D. 1948. A microchemical reaction resulting in the staining of polysaccharide structures in fixed tissue preparations. Archive of Biochemistry  16: 131.

 

Ichida, F., Shibaski, K. & Takino, T. 1982. Therapeutic effects of tiopronin on chronic hepatities. A double blind study. Journal of International Medical Research  10: 325-332.

 

Ishil, K., Matoma, S., Hisaoshibata, H., Okudiara, M. & Tsuchiya M. 1984. Microcirculatory response to estradiol benzoate in chronic liver damage induced by carbon tetrachloride in the rat. Gastroenterology  19: 419-423.

 

Itoh, K. 1988. The effect of carbon tetrachloride on albumin synthesis in rat with alcoholic liver injury. Journal of Medical Society of Tokyo University  34: 542-549.

 

Kansase, M. S, Patil, S. & Varute, A. T. 1986. Lipolytic activities of liver, kidney and adipose tissue of albino rat during carbon tetrachloride-induced hepatic injury. Journal of Bioscience 10: 227-237.

 

Kim, S. P. & Labella, F. S. 1987. Criteria for determination of lipid peroxidation in tissues: Estimation in liver of mice intoxicated with carbon tetrachloride. Canadian Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 65: 1503-1506.

 

Kumar, S. 1985. Studies on radioprotectors in mammals and their possible use in radiotherapy. Radiobiology and Radiotherapy 26: 359-365.

 

Kwon. J. J., Tack, L. J., Cho, K., Kim, Y. & Deog, Y. 1989. Protective effects of trithioformaledhyde (TTEA) on carbon tetrachloride in rats. Korean Journal of Pharmacology  25: 209-216.

 

Lamb, R. G., Mc Cue, S. B., Taylor, D. R. & Mcguffin, M. A. 1984. The role of phospholipid metabolism in bromobenzene and carbon tetrachloride dependent hepatocyte injury. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology  75: 510-520.

 

Lockard, V. G., Mehendale, H. M. & O’Neal, R. M. 1983. Chlordeconeinduced potentiation of carbon tetrachloide hepatotoxicity: Light and electron microscopic study. Experimental and Molecular Pathology  39: 239-245.

.

Mathur, V. B., Devi, P.M. & Bisht, K. S. 1986. Influence of 2-mercaptopropionyl glycine on radiation induced chagnes in acid phosphatase activity to mouse intestine and its role in tissue protection. Radiobiology Radiotherapy  27: 479-484.

 

Mazia, M., Brewer, P. A. & Affert, M. 1953. The cytochemical staining and measurments of protein with mercuric bromophenol blue. Biological Bulletin 104: 57-67.

McManus, J. F. & Mowry, R. W. 1960. Staining Methods: Histolgical and histochemical. Harper and Row, NewYork.

       

Moussa, T. A., El-Aaser, A. A. & El-Banhawy, M. A. 1984. Principles and practice of histochemistry. Dar Al-Maaref, Cairo, Egypt.

 

Pappas, N., John, J.R., Wisecarver, J. & Becker, S. 1984. Effect of cycloheximide on increased asparate aminotransferase in carbon tetrachloride hepatotoxicity. Annals of Clinical Laboratory Science  14: 40-46.

 

Poli, G., Gravela, E. Albono, E. & Dianzami, M. 1979. Studies on fatty livers with isolated hepatocytes. II. The action of carbon tetrachloride on lipid peroxidation and triglyceride synthesis and secretion. Experimental and Molecular Pathology, 30: 116-127.

 

Rastogi, S. & Rama, S. V. 1990. Influence of parathyroidectony on liver glycogen in rats treated with carbon tetrachloride. Indian Journal of Experimental Biology  28: 794-795.

 

Sakr, S. A. 1993. Effect of thiola on acetaminophen induced hepatic necrosis in mice. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 51: 808-813.

 

Sakr, S. A. Abdel-Aal., W. E., Boulos, M. N., Agamy, E. I., & Omara, E. A. 1994. Prevention by thiola of histological alteration in rat liver induced by carbon tetrachloride. Journal Egyptian Society of  Pathology  14: 451-458.

 

Sakr, S. A., El-Elaimy, I. A., El-Saadany, M. M. & El-Messady, F. A. 1993. Effect of thiola on methotrexate-induced hepatic injury in rats. II Histochemical studies. Journal of Egyptian Germany Society of Zoology  11: 207-223.

 

Sherlock, S. & Walshe, V. 1947. Hepatic alkaline phosphatase, histological and microchemical studies in normal subject and in liver and bone diseases. Journal of Pathology and Bactriology  59: 615-630.

 

Stowell, R. E., Lee, C. S., Tsubool, K. K. & Vilasana, V. 1950. Histochemical and microchemical changes in experimental cirrhosis and hepatoma formation in mice by carbon tetrachloride. Cancer Research 22: 345.

 

Sughora, T., Tanka, Y., Nagata, H, Kano, E. & Tanaka, T. 1970. Radiation protection by thiola. Proceeding International Symposium on thiola. Osaka, Japan, 267 pp.

 

Torriell, M. V., Franzone, S. & Haccavento, C. 1981. Hepatic fibrosis induced in the rat by combined treatment with carbon tetrachloride and ethanol. Activity of sulphydryle compounds. Recent Advances in 2-MPG treatment. Liver Disease 11: 119-122.

 

Trinus, F. P., Pisarev, A. A., Chubenko, A. V. & Sterfanov, A. V. 1986. Experimental morpholgical studies of liposome effect in carbon tetrachloride intoxication. Bulletin of Experimental Biology  100: 714-715.

 

Tsuji, T. & Nagashima, H. 1981. Follow up study in chronic active hepatities after therapy with immunosuppressive drugs and tiopronin. Gasteroentrolgy 16: 568-575.

 

Zimmerman, H. J. & Ishak, K. B. 1978. Hepatotoxicity injury due to drugs and toxins. In: Mac Seveen, R. N. M., Anthony, P. P. & Scheur, P. J. (eds.). Pathology of liver, 335 pp. Churchill livingstone, London.

 

 

 

(Received 1/1/1420; 17th April 1999, accepted 12/8/1420; 20th November 1999)